If you’ve read George R.R. Martin’s Dunk and Egg novellas, you probably have a very specific vision of these stories in your head. You know the characters’ voices, their mannerisms, the exact feel of the scenes. You’ve imagined the tournaments, the taverns, the tense political moments. So naturally, the prospect of seeing these beloved stories adapted into a major HBO series comes with both excitement and a fair amount of anxiety. Book readers are absolutely hoping the show gets certain things right—not just the big plot points, but the character moments, the emotional beats, the thematic undertones that make the novellas special. Let’s talk about what the book community is most eager to see on screen.
The Voice and Personality of Dunk
Dunk is the narrative heart of these novellas, and his voice—the way he thinks, the way he perceives the world—is essential to why readers connect with him. Dunk is not intellectual. He’s honest about his limitations. He doesn’t spend time in philosophical musings or sophisticated political analysis. He’s straightforward, sometimes to a fault. He cares deeply about being a good knight and living up to his oath, and he tends toward action rather than calculation. This directness is part of what makes him endearing.
One of the biggest hopes for the show is that the actor playing Dunk captures this quality—the genuine earnestness, the lack of pretense, the way Dunk sees the world in fairly black-and-white terms even as that worldview is increasingly challenged by the events around him. Dunk should never feel like he’s playing games or being clever. He should feel like an actual person trying his best to do right in an increasingly complicated situation. When he makes mistakes, they should feel like the mistakes of someone acting with incomplete information and good intentions, not the calculating errors of a more sophisticated character. The show needs to honor the fundamental decency that makes readers root for Dunk, even when his choices put him in danger.
Egg’s Duality and Secret Identity
Egg is the other essential character, and his story is about the tension between his public identity (a squire traveling with an older knight) and his hidden identity (Aegon Targaryen, a prince of the realm). Book readers who know the secrets that Dunk doesn’t know yet experience the novellas with this dramatic irony—understanding that Egg is not who he appears to be, watching Dunk gradually figure this out, and anticipating how Egg’s true identity will eventually complicate their relationship and their adventures.
What fans desperately hope the show gets right is the delicate balance between portraying Egg as a convincingly ordinary boy while also showing glimpses of the royal blood and royal thinking that define him. Egg should feel like a kid—sometimes petulant, sometimes trying to impress Dunk, sometimes genuinely scared. But he should also carry this weight of hidden destiny and future responsibility that’s not immediately obvious but becomes increasingly clear as the story develops. The actor needs to be able to do vulnerability and childishness while also conveying intelligence, dignity, and a particular kind of bravery that comes with knowing who you really are.
Part of what makes Egg compelling in the books is that he’s not a perfect character. He has the flaws and impulses of a boy, including selfishness and stubbornness. But he’s also shaped by his royal heritage and his understanding of what his position in the world means. The show needs to show all of this, not just the likable aspects. Readers want to see the complexity of a character who is simultaneously innocent and burdened by knowledge and status.
The Emotional Core of Their Relationship
While Dunk and Egg’s adventures involve tournaments, politics, and danger, the emotional core of their story is their relationship. It starts with Dunk taking on a responsibility for a boy he barely knows—he’s sworn an oath, and Dunk takes oaths seriously. As their relationship develops, it becomes genuinely affectionate. They become important to each other in ways that are unambiguous and uncomplicated, at least until outside forces start testing that bond.
Book readers are hoping the show spends real time developing this relationship. They want to see the moments where Dunk and Egg connect, where they trust each other, where they show genuine care for one another. They want to see the arguments and disagreements that come from people who care about each other but have different perspectives and desires. They want the relationship to feel earned, not declared. By the time the major dramatic moments happen that test Dunk and Egg’s connection, viewers should feel the weight of their bond and understand why it matters so much.
This means not rushing through character development in favor of plot. The novellas are relatively short, but they manage to build genuine feeling through careful attention to dialogue, small moments, and the accumulation of shared experiences. The show needs to adapt this with the understanding that character development and relationship-building are not filler—they’re the actual substance of these stories.
The Tournament Sequences: Spectacle and Substance
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms gives us multiple tournament scenes, and book readers are eagerly anticipating how HBO will bring these to life. The tournament is not just spectacle, though spectacle is part of it. The tournaments in the novellas are where major plot events occur, where character development happens, and where the larger political tensions simmer beneath the surface.
What readers hope for is that the show understands that these are not just action sequences. Yes, they should be well-choreographed and visually impressive. But they also need to convey the emotions and stakes of the characters involved. Dunk’s internal experience while competing—his focus, his determination, his fear—needs to be conveyed. The tension of watching someone you care about risk his life in combat needs to be felt. The political dimensions of the tournament—the alliances, the rivalries, the watching eyes of powerful people judging the competitors—need to be clear.
Additionally, book readers have specific expectations about how certain tournament moments play out. Major victories and defeats have consequences. The outcome of a particular joust can set off a chain of events that defines the rest of the novella. When these moments happen, they need to land with full dramatic weight. The show needs to make clear that what’s happening in the tournament grounds is not just entertainment—it’s the story of individuals struggling against fate and circumstance, their choices and their luck intertwining to create consequences that ripple outward.
The Political Intrigue and the Blackfyre Question
One of the aspects of Dunk and Egg that becomes increasingly important as the novellas progress is the political dimension. The realm is not at peace, even if it’s not openly at war. There’s the question of the Blackfyres, the shadow of the Targaryen civil conflict, and the tensions between various powerful families and factions. Dunk gradually becomes aware that larger political forces are at work around him, and Egg is actually at the center of some of these tensions.
Book readers are hoping the show makes this political dimension clear without allowing it to overwhelm the personal story. The political intrigue should enhance the tension and the stakes of Dunk and Egg’s journey, but it shouldn’t become the main focus. The show needs to balance the intimate, personal story of two characters traveling together with the larger historical and political context that shapes their world. Readers want to understand what’s really going on politically, but they don’t want that to replace the emotional core of the story.
This also means getting the characterization of the historical and political figures right. Characters like King Aerys II and the various lords and ladies Dunk and Egg encounter need to feel like real people with their own motivations and perspectives, not just plot devices. When Dunk encounters authority figures, readers want to understand their positions and their reasoning, even when Dunk himself might not fully grasp it.
The Themes of Honor and Compromise
Throughout the novellas, Dunk wrestles with what it means to be honorable in a world where honor doesn’t always lead to success or safety. He faces situations where doing the right thing could cost him everything. He witnesses people compromising their principles for advantage. He considers compromise himself. Book readers are eager to see the show engage seriously with these themes rather than treating them as abstract ideals.
When Dunk is tempted to act dishonorably—to betray someone, to pursue advantage at the expense of principle—readers hope the show conveys the genuine cost of such choices. It’s not that Dunk automatically does the right thing; it’s that he struggles with these decisions and chooses integrity despite the personal cost. This is more compelling than a character who simply never faces real temptation or who never struggles with moral choices. The show needs to make clear that Dunk’s honor is something he actively chooses, again and again, even when it’s difficult.
Supporting Characters and Their Complexity
While Dunk and Egg are the protagonists, the novellas are populated with supporting characters who have their own agendas, their own struggles, and their own moral dimensions. Some of these characters are helpful to Dunk and Egg; others are obstacles or threats. Some are sympathetic; others are not. But none of them are simple cartoons.
Book readers are hoping the show gives these characters real depth. When someone opposes Dunk or Egg, readers want to understand why from their perspective, not just from Dunk’s. When someone helps them, the motivation should feel real and earned. Secondary characters should feel like complete people with their own stakes in what’s happening, not just functions in Dunk and Egg’s story. This kind of complexity is what elevated George R.R. Martin’s work in the main Game of Thrones series, and it’s present in the Dunk and Egg novellas as well.
The Tone and Atmosphere
The Dunk and Egg novellas have a particular tone that readers have come to love. They’re not as dark as the main Game of Thrones books, but they’re not light either. There’s humor, there’s genuine affection, there’s adventure, but there’s also the constant awareness of danger and consequence. The world feels lived-in and real. The poverty that Dunk experiences, the risk of injury in tournaments, the power imbalances between common knights and nobility—all of this feels present and consequential.
Book readers are hoping the show captures this tone—a world that’s neither cynically dark nor naively optimistic, but something more complex and real. Humor, when it appears, should feel earned and character-appropriate, not forced. Moments of genuine joy or connection should feel precious because they exist in a world where things can go wrong quickly. The show should never lose the sense that Dunk and Egg are vulnerable, that consequences matter, and that their survival is not guaranteed.
Conclusion: Faithful to the Spirit, Not Just the Letter
What book readers ultimately hope for is that “A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms” understands what makes the novellas special and brings that to the screen. This doesn’t necessarily mean perfect scene-for-scene adaptation of every moment from the books. It means capturing the emotional truth of these stories, the complexity of the characters, the balance between intimacy and spectacle, and the thematic concerns that drive the narrative.
Fans are hoping for a show that respects George R.R. Martin’s source material not by being slavishly literal but by understanding what made people connect with these stories in the first place and finding ways to convey that in a visual medium. If the show succeeds, even viewers who haven’t read the novellas will understand why these stories matter to the broader Game of Thrones universe and why the character of Dunk and the relationship between Dunk and Egg have captured readers’ imaginations. That’s what the book community is hoping for—not just a faithful adaptation, but a true translation of the novellas’ spirit to the screen.
Discover more from Anglotees
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.