Matt Smith’s portrayal of Daemon Targaryen is one of those performances that just grabs you and doesn’t let go. He’s charismatic, he’s dangerous, he’s funny, he’s tragic, and he’s absolutely unhinged in all the best ways. And here’s the thing that makes him interesting: you can watch ten different people watch House of the Dragon and get ten different takes on whether Daemon is an antihero rooting for his family’s survival or a villain who’s manipulating everyone around him to feed his own ego and ambition. The show deliberately keeps this tension alive, and that’s what makes Daemon such a fascinating character.
The Rogue Prince as Narrative Wildcard
When we first meet Daemon, he’s the Rogue Prince of the realm — a man who’s been exiled by his own brother, who’s living in Essos and presumably causing trouble wherever he goes. He’s disreputable, he has a bad reputation, and there’s clearly bad blood between him and King Viserys. Everything about his introduction suggests that he’s going to be a antagonist, a chaos agent who’s going to cause problems for the main characters. He’s not even particularly likable in those early scenes. He’s boastful, he’s dismissive of his brother, and he seems to be motivated by nothing but his own pride and desire for wealth and power.
But here’s where it gets interesting. Daemon starts out as a joke — the embarrassing problem child of the royal family — and gradually becomes essential to the Blacks’ entire cause. He goes from being exiled and powerless to being one of the most important military strategists the Blacks have, the man who’s flying Caraxes in battle and winning them victories. He transforms from a liability into an asset, and the question of whether he’s actually changed or whether everyone else just finally recognizes what he’s capable of is something the show never quite answers. That ambiguity is the genius of his character arc.
The Scarlet and the Black: Daemon’s War
Daemon’s motivations are genuinely unclear, and that’s the point. Is he fighting for his family? Is he fighting for the Blacks and their claim? Is he fighting for the pure joy of destruction and the power that comes with riding a dragon into battle? The answer is probably all three, and the show is smart enough not to try to simplify it. When Daemon goes to the Riverlands and wages what amounts to a reign of terror against the Greens’ forces, he’s using the same brutal tactics that got him exiled in the first place. He’s causing destruction, he’s killing people, and he’s doing it with a smile on his face because he loves the power and the chaos.
The question is: is that character flaw something that serves the Blacks’ cause, or is it something that ultimately undermines them? Daemon is a killer, and he’s good at killing. The Blacks need someone who can kill people effectively. But Daemon’s killing is also driven by something personal, something almost sadistic. He doesn’t kill for the cause — he kills because he wants to, and the cause just happens to give him a legitimate reason to do what he already wants to do anyway.
This is where Matt Smith’s performance really shines. He manages to play Daemon as both a man who genuinely cares about his family and a man who’s using his family’s cause as an excuse to indulge his worst impulses. And the brilliant part is that both of those things are true at the same time. You can’t untangle Daemon’s genuine love for Rhaenyra from his personal ambition and need for power and recognition. They’re all mixed up together, and trying to separate them would be impossible. That’s what makes him so compelling — he’s not a simple villain, but he’s not a simple hero either. He’s a complicated person doing complicated things for complicated reasons.
The Man Who Wanted to be Important
At the core of Daemon’s character is a deep need to be recognized, to be important, to be powerful. His entire arc is defined by his brother’s failures to acknowledge him, his position as second son, his exile from power and legitimacy. When Viserys names Rhaenyra as heir, it’s not because of anything Daemon did or because Daemon is in favor with the king. It’s a purely dynastic decision that has nothing to do with Daemon’s worth or capability. And that’s infuriating to Daemon. He wants power, yes, but more than that, he wants to matter. He wants people to acknowledge that he’s important.
The genius of Daemon’s character is that he’s deeply insecure beneath all that arrogant bluster. He’s a prince of the realm, he’s a dragon rider, he’s probably one of the most capable warriors alive, and he’s still not good enough. His brother treats him like a problem child. His own family doesn’t take him seriously until it’s too late. Even when he’s helping win battles for the Blacks, there’s always this undercurrent of resentment and bitterness because he’s not being given the credit he thinks he deserves.
Daemon and Rhaenyra: A Marriage of Ambition and Trauma
His marriage to Rhaenyra is probably the clearest window into Daemon’s character. He’s been in love with her for a long time — the show makes it clear that his feelings for her are genuine — but his proposal is also calculated. By marrying Rhaenyra, he’s not just gaining a partnership with someone he loves; he’s finally getting access to real power. He’s finally the man at the side of someone important. He’s finally going to matter in a way that his brother never allowed him to.
The question of whether Daemon is a good partner to Rhaenyra is complicated. He clearly cares about her, but he also clearly cares about power, and those two things are not always aligned. When Rhaenyra needs a supportive partner, Daemon is there. But when Daemon wants to wage war and cause destruction, he’s going to do that regardless of what Rhaenyra thinks. He’s a man who’s been told his entire life that he’s a problem, and now he’s finally found a situation where being a problem is actually useful. That doesn’t mean he’s going to change his fundamental nature just because he’s married to the woman he loves.
The Tragic Fall of the Rogue Prince
What’s devastating about Daemon’s arc is that he never really gets what he’s looking for. He gains power, he gains a position of importance, he gains the respect of warriors and soldiers who follow him into battle. But he never gets the full legitimacy he craves. He’s always going to be the rogue prince, the man who’s slightly too dangerous, slightly too unpredictable. Even his own wife is wary of him sometimes. And the closer he gets to having everything he wants, the more it seems to slip away from him.
By the end of the season, Daemon is losing everything. His marriage is fractured. Rhaenyra is increasingly disillusioned with him. The war that he was so good at waging is turning into a grinding, brutal conflict with no clear end. And Daemon, for all his power and his dragon and his skill as a warrior, can’t change any of that. He’s a chaos agent in a situation that demands stability. He’s a warmonger in a situation that increasingly seems unwinnable through warfare. The tragedy of Daemon is that his greatest strengths — his ability to destroy, his willingness to do terrible things, his refusal to accept authority — are exactly the wrong tools for what’s actually needed to win this war.
Antihero, Villain, or Just a Man?
So, is Daemon an antihero or a villain? The answer is probably that he’s neither and both at the same time. He’s not a hero — there’s too much darkness in him, too much genuine cruelty and selfishness. But he’s not a villain either — his love for his family is genuine, his courage is real, and his cause is as legitimate as anyone else’s in this conflict. He’s a man who’s motivated by complicated desires — love, power, recognition, legitimacy — and who pursues those desires in ways that are sometimes noble and sometimes monstrous.
The genius of Matt Smith’s performance is that he never tries to smooth out these contradictions. He doesn’t play Daemon as someone who’s trying to be good but failing, or someone who’s evil with a soft side. He plays him as someone who contains multitudes — he’s capable of genuine love and genuine cruelty, often in the same scene. He’s a man who would die for the people he loves and also burn cities for personal satisfaction. Those things don’t cancel each other out. They just exist together, which is what makes him so much more interesting than a straightforward villain would be.
Conclusion: The Rogue Prince Remains Unresolved
What makes Daemon such a compelling character is that the show never quite resolves the central question of what he really is. Is he a necessary weapon for the Blacks, or a destructive liability? Is he genuinely in love with Rhaenyra, or is he using that love as a justification for pursuing his own ambitions? Is he heroic, villainous, or just a man struggling with his own nature? The answer, the show suggests, is that it’s all of these things depending on how you look at it, and the attempt to pin Daemon down to a single category is probably a fool’s errand.
That’s what makes him such great television. He’s unpredictable, he’s compelling, and he’s genuinely fascinating to watch. Matt Smith gives a performance that’s magnetic and chaotic and deeply human, and he makes you understand why Rhaenyra loves him even as you’re watching him do things that would break anyone’s faith in a partner. Daemon is the Rogue Prince because he can never quite be tamed or categorized or made simple. And that’s exactly why he’s so memorable.
Discover more from Anglotees
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.