One of the central themes of Game of Thrones was the brutal reality of Westeros’s feudal system and how that system grinds down those without power or high birth. Jon Snow, Tyrion Lannister, Arya Stark—the narrative repeatedly centered on characters struggling against or within the limitations imposed by birth and social status. But where Game of Thrones sometimes showed us the brutality of the class system from the perspective of those who had some ability to resist it, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms forces us to confront the class system from the perspective of someone at the absolute bottom. Dunk the Tall is a hedge knight—lowborn, with no lands, no name, no family connections. He’s trying to navigate a world that is explicitly and unapologetically structured against people like him, and the show doesn’t shy away from showing us exactly how cruel that system is.
The brilliance of using Dunk as the central character is that his entire story is one long encounter with the arbitrary limitations that Westeros’s class system imposes. Every situation he faces, he faces differently than a highborn character would face it. Every door that’s open to a noble is closed to him. Every circumstance that might pass unquestioned in a highborn person becomes potentially catastrophic when he’s the one involved. A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms uses Dunk’s perspective to give us a masterclass in how feudal hierarchy actually functions in practice, and why it’s so insidious and difficult to escape.
The Violence of Hierarchy
The most striking thing about watching Dunk navigate Westeros is recognizing just how much of the violence of the system is built into normal interactions. Nobody needs to pull a sword on Dunk to make his life difficult. The system already does that work. When he enters a tavern, people automatically assume he’s there to work or to serve, not to belong. When he claims to be a knight, people are skeptical because his appearance doesn’t match the expectation of what a knight looks like. When he asks for a fair hearing, he gets one if and only if the person with power decides to give one to him.
This is what A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms understands so well: the class system doesn’t just function through dramatic violence. It functions through thousands of small moments where someone’s social status determines how they’re treated. It functions through assumptions and expectations. It functions through access to resources and information. When Dunk needs to find work, he can’t just go to the castle and apply for a position. He has to perform his lowborn role correctly, understand the unwritten rules, navigate a system designed to keep him in his place.
The show demonstrates this through action rather than exposition. We watch Dunk trying to figure out what people expect from him. We watch him attempt to claim a place in society and get rejected not because he lacks ability or courage, but because he lacks the right birth. We watch him constantly apologizing for existing in spaces that he technically has the right to exist in, simply because his status makes him feel like an intruder. This is the violence of hierarchy—it doesn’t always announce itself loudly. Often it’s just the constant, grinding pressure of knowing you’re not supposed to be here.
The Impossibility of Upward Mobility
For much of the series, Dunk’s arc is defined by his attempt to become a legitimate knight. He was sworn to Ser Arlen as a squire—impoverished and informal, but still technically sworn. When Ser Arlen dies, Dunk claims the position of knight, though he’s never been formally knighted. This lie is both everything and nothing. It gives him the social cover he needs to move through the world, but he’s constantly aware that it’s illegitimate, that he has no real claim to knighthood, that anyone could expose him.
The show doesn’t let us pretend that Dunk’s situation is simple. His desire to become a knight isn’t just about ambition. It’s about survival in a world where a lowborn person without a lord or a guild has almost no way to support themselves. Being a knight—even a poor, hedge knight—is one of the few pathways available to someone of low birth who doesn’t want to be a peasant, a servant, or a criminal. But even that pathway is precarious because the system fundamentally doubts people like him.
What’s remarkable is how the show portrays the actual mechanisms through which upward mobility is supposed to work, and how those mechanisms are practically impossible for someone without family or connections. Yes, theoretically a lowborn person can become a knight through skill and service. But in practice, becoming a knight requires access to training, armor, a horse—things that require either money or sponsorship, both of which are extremely difficult for someone with nothing. The class system isn’t just unfair; it’s architecturally designed to make upward mobility nearly impossible.
The Economics of Lowborn Status
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms does something that Game of Thrones didn’t always do: it pays close attention to economics. The show is very aware that Dunk’s life is shaped as much by money—or rather, the lack thereof—as it is by his social status. He doesn’t have enough money to eat regularly. He has to be strategic about spending on armor and supplies. He has to take whatever work he can find because he can’t afford to be selective.
This economic reality has enormous consequences for how Dunk moves through the world. He can’t afford to offend a potential patron even when they’re treating him disrespectfully. He can’t afford to make choices based on principle if those choices would cost him money. He can’t afford to rest or take time to think. He has to keep moving, keep working, keep trying to turn his labor into enough coins to survive. The show demonstrates how poverty and low birth combine to create a system where someone like Dunk has almost no agency.
This is particularly clear in scenes where Dunk encounters people of actual wealth, even lowborn wealth. Characters who have money—merchants, successful innkeeps, people with land—operate with a kind of freedom that Dunk simply doesn’t have. They can negotiate. They can make choices. They can afford to take risks. Dunk can’t. The show understands that class isn’t just about birth or social status—it’s about material resources, and those material resources create enormous power differentials.
The Cruelty of Arbitrary Authority
One of the most striking aspects of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is how it portrays the arbitrary nature of authority in a feudal system. A lord is a lord because he was born to a lord, or because someone powerful decided he was a lord. His authority doesn’t require consent from those under him. It doesn’t require approval or justification. When a lord says something is true, it becomes true. When a lord decides something is just, it becomes just, at least as far as the people under his authority are concerned.
Dunk encounters this repeatedly. A lord can decide to strip him of his honor on a whim. A lord can make an unreasonable demand and expect it to be obeyed. A lord can punish someone harshly simply because they had the power to do so. There’s no appeal, no justice in any objective sense. There’s just the will of the person with power and the forced compliance of those without it. The show doesn’t present this as unique or exceptional—it’s just how the system works.
What makes this particularly cruel is that Dunk, despite being lowborn, has a sense of honor and fairness that makes him chafe against these arbitrary exercises of power. He wants to believe that there’s some kind of justice in the world, some kind of rule of law that applies equally to everyone. But the system consistently shows him that there isn’t. You can be treated unfairly, and that unfairness is just how things are. You can be punished for something you didn’t do, and that’s just the consequence of having less power. The system doesn’t owe you fairness. It only owes fairness to people of sufficient status.
Respectability and the Performance of Class
A subtle but important aspect of the class system that A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms explores is the way that class position can be performed and maintained through the right behavior. Dunk constantly has to perform his lowborn status correctly. He has to know when to bow, when to speak, when to stay silent. He has to use the right language, maintain the right posture, show the right deference.
The show demonstrates that social class isn’t just about birth—it’s also about a set of behaviors and markers that signal where you belong. Someone who dresses like a knight but acts like a peasant creates cognitive dissonance. Someone who speaks without proper deference to a highborn person is transgressing. The class system maintains itself partly through these performances, and people like Dunk are very aware that stepping out of their assigned role has consequences.
This also reveals something important about the system: it’s maintained not just through law and force, but through a kind of social agreement about who belongs where and how. If everyone with power collectively decided to stop treating lowborn people as inferior, the system would break down. But that collective decision never happens, which is why the system endures even without constant explicit enforcement.
The Contradictions of the System
One of the things that makes A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms interesting is that it doesn’t present the class system as perfectly coherent. There are contradictions and cracks in the logic. Knights are supposed to be protectors of the weak, yet the system itself is designed to keep weak people weak. Nobility is supposed to be earned through service, yet birth determines status. The system claims to offer paths for upward mobility, yet those paths are essentially closed to anyone without existing resources.
Dunk is acutely aware of these contradictions, and his interactions with other characters often circle around them. When he meets a noble who’s acting dishonorably, Dunk is troubled because knighthood and honor are supposed to go together. When he sees lords abusing their power, he’s troubled because they’re supposed to protect their subjects. The show uses Dunk’s perspective to make the audience aware of these contradictions as well. We start to notice that the system isn’t just unfair—it’s also full of internal failures and hypocrisies.
The Randomness of Fortune
What makes the class system even more brutal in A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is that so much depends on luck and circumstance. Dunk’s entire situation changes because he happened to meet Egg. He gets certain opportunities because he happens to be in certain places at certain times. One chance meeting with a highborn person can completely change his prospects. The system is so rigid that individual chance becomes enormously important—you’re trapped in your class unless something random and lucky happens to you.
The show demonstrates that this randomness is actually a feature of the system, not a bug. As long as the system can point to occasional success stories—lowborn people who somehow made it—it can claim that the system is fair and that anyone can rise if they work hard enough. But in reality, those success stories are rare and based as much on luck as on merit. The system itself isn’t designed to lift people up. It’s designed to keep them in place, with just enough possibility of escape that people will keep trying.
Conclusion: The Unbearable Weight of Low Birth
A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms uses Dunk’s lowborn status not as an obstacle to overcome (though it is that), but as a fundamental lens through which we understand the world. Every episode, in every scene, we’re reminded that Dunk’s life is shaped by a system that doesn’t care about his abilities or his honor or his dreams. The system just sees his low birth and treats him accordingly.
This is what makes the show’s portrayal of class so devastating and so important. It doesn’t let us escape into the fantasy of a meritocratic system where hard work and virtue eventually triumph. It shows us that systems of class and status are maintained through thousands of small moments, through economics and arbitrary authority and the performance of deference, and that they’re incredibly difficult to escape.
The cruelty of Westeros’s class system has always been central to Game of Thrones, but A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms brings that cruelty into sharp focus by following someone trapped at the bottom. When you see the world through Dunk’s eyes, you understand viscerally why the feudal system is so brutal and why escaping it feels almost impossible. And that understanding makes the show’s final message—whatever it is—all the more powerful. Because we’ll understand, in our bones, just how much Dunk has had to overcome.
Discover more from Anglotees
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.