Game of Thrones is full of amazing characters. It’s also full of characters who started amazing and then basically disappeared from the narrative without proper resolution. These aren’t minor characters—they’re experienced warriors, brilliant strategists, and deeply compelling figures who, at various points in the series, seemed poised to play major roles in the endgame. But as the show rushed through its final seasons, as the writers decided which characters deserved screen time and which ones could be quietly written off, a surprising number of genuinely great characters fell through the cracks. They got shoved to the side, their storylines abandoned, their potential unrealized. It’s one of the show’s great failures, and it’s worth examining exactly who got left behind and what we lost by forgetting them.
Barristan Selmy: The Warrior Who Became Irrelevant
Barristan Selmy is one of the greatest knights in Westerosi history. He’s served kings, saved Daenerys’s life multiple times, and becomes one of the most important advisors in her council. He’s introduced as a legendary warrior, and Sean Bean plays him with such gravitas and honor that you immediately understand why everyone respects him. He’s the show’s embodiment of the old ways, of chivalry and honor and loyalty. He’s also one of the few genuinely good people in the entire series, someone who actually cares about justice and honor rather than power.
And then the show just… forgets about him. In Season 5, Daenerys sends him away without really explaining why, and from that point on, Barristan is effectively gone. He’s in Meereen, dealing with political crises, but none of it gets screen time. None of his advice matters. He goes from being one of the central figures in Daenerys’s story to being a character who might as well not exist. When he dies—and he does eventually die, offscreen basically, mentioned in passing—it barely registers. You have to think hard to remember that he’s even dead, which tells you how completely sidelined he’d become.
What makes this worse is that Barristan was positioned to be so much more important. He’s a living connection to the history of the realm. He’s someone who could have served as moral ballast for Daenerys, who desperately needed someone willing to tell her when she was wrong. He’s a warrior who fought in wars that shaped the entire history of the continent, and his perspectives and experiences matter. Instead, he gets sent away and forgotten, and the space he might have filled is left empty.
The Blackfish: The Tactical Genius Who Got Trapped
The Blackfish, Brynden Tully, is introduced as something like the personification of strategic brilliance. He’s an old man, but he’s sharp, experienced, and when the Stark family needs help, he’s there with concrete advice and tactical expertise. He fights in the War of the Five Kings with distinction. He organizes defensive strategies. He’s tough as nails and utterly committed to the principles of honor and loyalty that the older generation in Westeros supposedly values.
And then Riverrun happens. The Blackfish gets trapped in Riverrun, dealing with Lannister armies outside the castle walls, trying to hold onto one of the most strategically important locations in the Reach. And the show… just ends his story there. Literally. He dies offscreen, mentioned in casual conversation, and we never see it. A man who could have been a crucial advisor to the Starks, who could have played a major role in the endgame, basically just disappears from the narrative when his location becomes inconvenient to the plot.
What’s particularly frustrating is that the Blackfish had so much more to give. He understood military strategy better than almost anyone else in the realm. He was loyal to the Stark family. He was tough and experienced and capable of genuine wisdom. The show killed him off not because his character arc demanded it, but because the narrative had moved on and they didn’t want to figure out how to incorporate him anymore. It’s a waste of a great character and a great performance.
Doran Martell: The Mastermind Who Never Got to Execute His Plan
Doran Martell is introduced as the Prince of Dorne, a man who’s been planning his revenge against the Lannisters for years. He’s methodical, careful, and seemingly brilliant. He’s been working toward an end goal that will take decades to achieve, and he’s patient enough to do it. The show builds him up as someone with a secret plan, someone who understands the long game in a way most of the other rulers don’t. He’s got dragons coming, he’s got legitimate grievances, and he’s got the intelligence and patience to act on them effectively.
And then Season 6 happens, and his eldest daughter basically says “no, we’re doing things my way instead,” and Doran gets killed. Not in a meaningful conflict, not because his plan failed for understandable reasons, but because the show decided it was more efficient to just get rid of him and replace him with a more aggressive leader. One of the most interesting political minds in the entire realm is disposed of because the show wanted to speed up the Dorne plot.
The thing about Doran is that he represented something important: patience, long-term thinking, and the kind of strategic brilliance that comes from genuine experience and understanding. Everyone else in Game of Thrones is reacting to immediate crises. Doran is playing a game that spans decades. That’s fascinating. That’s compelling. And the show just threw it away because his character was inconvenient.
Minor Characters With Major Potential
But it’s not just the big figures who got lost. There are dozens of secondary characters who seemed poised to matter more as the show progressed and then just disappeared. What about Davos Seaworth, who had actual moral convictions and strategic value? He’s still in the show technically, but his importance diminishes as the seasons go on. What about Theon Greyjoy, who gets a redemption arc that’s compelling until the show basically ends it abruptly? What about the Night’s King, who the show never properly explains despite introducing him as this terrifying existential threat?
There’s also characters like the Sand Snakes, who could have been interesting if they’d been given actual screen time and development instead of getting introduced as cartoon villains. There’s Daenerys’s kingsguard, who had potential. There’s pretty much the entire leadership structure of King’s Landing after Cersei—the people actually trying to govern the destroyed city, the people cleaning up her mess. They exist, but they don’t matter because the show has already decided the story is over.
Why Does It Matter?
Here’s the thing: Game of Thrones isn’t just a story about the main characters. It’s supposed to be about a world, about the complex interplay of forces and personalities that shape history. When you sideline characters like Barristan, the Blackfish, and Doran Martell, you’re losing crucial perspectives and tactical expertise. You’re losing the voice of experience, the wisdom of people who’ve been through these conflicts before. You’re left with a set of young, passionate, often inexperienced people making massive decisions without the counterweight of experienced advisors.
Daenerys desperately needed Barristan to tell her when she was wrong. The Starks desperately needed the Blackfish’s tactical knowledge. Dorne desperately needed Doran’s patient wisdom. Instead, they got hastier decisions, worse outcomes, and plots that felt rushed because the people who could have slowed things down and forced more careful consideration were gone.
The characters who got forgotten are important because they represent the institutional knowledge of Westeros. They’re the people who remember the last war, who understand the complexities of governance, who can advise younger leaders about the consequences of their actions. When you kill them off or sideline them, you’re left with a world that’s increasingly chaotic because there’s no one with the experience to say “wait, this is a bad idea, here’s what happened the last time someone tried this.”
The Larger Problem
These forgotten characters point to a larger issue with Game of Thrones’ later seasons: the show became increasingly focused on moving toward an ending rather than actually exploring the world it had built. It became more interested in shock moments and dramatic reveals than in letting characters develop naturally. It became faster, more impatient, less willing to sit with complexity.
A show with more time, with writers more interested in the full scope of the story, would have found space for Barristan’s wisdom. It would have paid attention to the Blackfish’s strategic genius. It would have let Doran’s plan actually matter. But Game of Thrones in its later seasons was so focused on getting to the next major plot point that it lost interest in the slow, careful development of character and strategy that made the earlier seasons so compelling.
The forgotten characters are a reminder of what Game of Thrones could have been if it had trusted its own complexity, if it had believed that the world it had built was interesting enough to justify a slower pace. Barristan Selmy didn’t need to fight in Meereen. But he deserved a proper ending, a meaningful exit from the story. The Blackfish didn’t need to single-handedly save the North. But he deserved to at least be on screen when his story ended. Doran Martell’s plan didn’t need to succeed completely. But it deserved to at least fail on screen, in a way that was meaningful and dramatic rather than just in passing.
These characters mattered. They represented important ideas about loyalty, about honor, about the value of experience and wisdom. And the fact that the show forgot them or sidelined them is one of its great tragedies. Because in forgetting them, Game of Thrones forgot some of what made it great in the first place: the belief that every character, even the ones without dragons or armies, could matter if they were written with enough depth and complexity. The show eventually decided that wasn’t true anymore. And we lost some genuinely great characters because of it.
Discover more from Anglotees
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.