In a world where power is typically understood to flow from military strength, political connections, and access to wealth and lands, there’s another form of power that’s often overlooked: knowledge. The Maesters of Westeros represent an interesting counterpoint to the traditional power structures of the Seven Kingdoms. They’re men (and women, though the order is primarily male) dedicated to the pursuit of learning, the preservation of knowledge, and the application of that knowledge to improve the realm. They serve as advisors to lords, as healers, as scholars, and as a kind of institutional check on the power of the nobility. In A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, the Citadel and the Maesters play an important but subtle role in exploring how knowledge and learning shape the world.
The Citadel: A Unique Institution
The Citadel is perhaps unique among the institutions of Westeros in that it’s fundamentally dedicated to learning and advancement based on merit rather than on birth or noble lineage. You don’t need to be the son of a great lord to become a Maester. You don’t need vast wealth or political connections. What you need is intelligence, dedication, and a willingness to put in the work required to master the various branches of knowledge that the Citadel teaches. It’s one of the few places in Westeros where a person of humble birth can rise through excellence alone.
This makes the Citadel fundamentally different from the rest of Westeros society, which is dominated by hereditary nobility and inherited titles. A noble is born to his position. A knight can be made through the right connections. But a Maester has to earn his place through study and examination. He has to prove his competence before he’s allowed to practice. The institution itself is designed to prioritize knowledge and ability over birth and connections. It’s almost revolutionary in its meritocratic approach.
The white robes of the Maesters are a symbol of this. When a man puts on those robes, he’s joining an institution that extends beyond any one lord or kingdom. He’s part of a network of learned men who serve the realm as a whole. He’s bound by oaths to serve knowledge and to use that knowledge for the good of the people. This makes Maesters uniquely positioned as a kind of neutral authority in the political conflicts of Westeros. They’re supposed to be above the fray, dedicated to healing and learning rather than to the pursuit of power.
Knowledge as a Different Kind of Power
Throughout the Game of Thrones universe, we see examples of how knowledge can be as powerful as swords. A Maester who understands poisons can influence the course of events. A historian who knows the old secrets of the Targaryen dynasty possesses information that kings would kill for. A scientist who understands the properties of wildfire or glass candles has access to power that transcends traditional military might. Knowledge isn’t always more powerful than a sword, but in the right circumstances, it’s immensely valuable.
In A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, this dynamic plays out in interesting ways. We encounter Maesters who are trying to preserve knowledge, trying to understand the world, trying to help their lords make better decisions. At the same time, we see that knowledge is often undervalued in a world that respects military might and political ruthlessness. A Maester’s advice can be ignored. A lord can choose to trust his instincts over learning and scholarship. The institutions that preserve and transmit knowledge are important, but they’re also vulnerable to the whims of powerful men who don’t see the value in learning.
This tension between the importance of knowledge and its vulnerability in a world dominated by power is at the heart of Martin’s portrayal of the Maesters and the Citadel. Knowledge matters, but only insofar as someone with the power to act on it chooses to listen. A brilliant scholar serving a foolish lord might as well be ignorant, because his wisdom will be ignored. The Citadel’s power is real, but it’s conditional on being respected and listened to by those who hold political and military power.
The Maester as Advisor and Confidant
In practice, the Maesters who appear throughout A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms and the Game of Thrones universe serve as trusted advisors to lords and kings. They’re educated men in a world where education is rare. They have access to information, libraries, and learning that even powerful nobles might lack. They’re often the most learned person in a lord’s household, which gives them a unique position of influence and authority.
This raises interesting questions about the balance of power in medieval Westeros. A lord may have the military strength and political authority, but his Maester may have the knowledge and wisdom to guide him toward better decisions. In theory, this is a healthy balance — the lord has the power to act, and the Maester has the knowledge to advise. In practice, it depends entirely on whether the lord respects his Maester’s counsel and is willing to listen to advice even when it contradicts his own instincts.
The tragedy of many situations in Game of Thrones is that lords don’t listen to their Maesters. They ignore medical advice, historical precedent, and scientific knowledge in favor of their own desires or gut instincts. They treat their Maesters as servants rather than as sources of legitimate expertise. This leads to bad decisions, failed strategies, and preventable suffering. If only more lords had been willing to respect the knowledge and wisdom of their Maesters, perhaps many of the tragedies of the series could have been avoided.
The Pursuit of Understanding
Beyond their practical role as advisors and healers, the Maesters are also engaged in the larger project of understanding how the world actually works. They study the movements of celestial bodies. They experiment with the properties of various substances. They keep records of history and precedent. They’re trying to map out the natural world and to understand it in terms that go beyond superstition and ancient legend. In a world where magic is real but mysterious, where the past is often shrouded in myth and legend, the Maesters represent a commitment to rational investigation and empirical knowledge.
This is particularly interesting in the context of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, which is set in an era before much of the magic and supernatural elements have faded from the world. We have dragons, we have the Others (even if they’re mostly forgotten), we have the old magic of the Children of the Forest. Yet the Maesters are still dedicated to understanding the world through reason and investigation. They’re not trying to deny that magic exists. They’re trying to understand how it works in the same way they try to understand the properties of herbs and the treatment of wounds.
This tension between the magical and the rational is one of the fascinating aspects of the Game of Thrones universe, and the Maesters represent the rational side of that equation. They’re the voice saying “we don’t fully understand this yet, but we can learn” rather than the voice saying “this is how it’s always been, don’t question it.” The Citadel’s commitment to learning and investigation is a form of intellectual courage that’s rare in a world where the status quo is generally accepted without question.
The Network of Knowledge
One thing that’s often overlooked is that the Maesters aren’t isolated individuals. They’re part of a network that extends across the entire realm. They communicate with each other, they share knowledge, they build on each other’s discoveries. The Citadel functions almost like a medieval university or think tank, with Maesters constantly pushing the boundaries of what’s known and understood. When one Maester makes a discovery or develops a new treatment, that knowledge is eventually shared with the broader network of Maesters across the realm.
This network is remarkably powerful when you think about it. It’s a system for preserving and transmitting knowledge that operates somewhat independently of the political power structures of the realm. A Maester’s knowledge doesn’t depend on his lord’s success or failure. It’s shared regardless of whether the current political situation is favorable to the transmission of information. In a world as fractious and violent as Westeros, having a network dedicated to the preservation and sharing of knowledge is genuinely valuable.
At the same time, this network is vulnerable. The Maesters depend on the patronage of the lords they serve. They depend on stable enough conditions to do their work. During times of war and chaos, the work of the Citadel is disrupted. Important knowledge might be lost. The network might be broken. We’ve seen in the Game of Thrones universe how close the Maesters come to losing crucial knowledge, how fragile the institutions that preserve learning can be in a world of violence and upheaval.
Knowledge and Morality
An interesting aspect of the Maesters in A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is the question of whether knowledge is morally neutral or whether the pursuit of knowledge carries moral responsibility. The Maesters are generally portrayed as dedicated to learning and to helping humanity through that learning. But there’s always the potential for knowledge to be misused. Poisons developed for legitimate medical purposes can be used to murder. An understanding of nutrition can be used to poison slowly over time. The tools of learning can be weaponized.
The Citadel, by maintaining high standards of training and by requiring oaths from those who join, attempts to ensure that knowledge is used for good purposes. But the institution can’t fully control how knowledge is used once it’s possessed. A Maester might betray his oaths. Knowledge might be misappropriated. Learning that was developed to help people might be twisted toward evil purposes. This is part of the complexity of the Maesters’ role in the world of Westeros. They’re committed to the pursuit of knowledge, but they’re also aware that knowledge can be dangerous if it falls into the wrong hands.
The Future of Learning
In A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, we’re seeing the Citadel and the Maesters during a relatively stable era of Westeros history. The institutions are functioning, knowledge is being preserved and transmitted, and the network of Maesters is working to improve the realm. Yet we know from the broader Game of Thrones timeline that eventually, the Maesters will decline in importance and influence. The great libraries will be lost. Much of the learning that existed in this era will be forgotten. The world will grow darker and more ignorant.
This retrospective knowledge gives a poignant quality to the scenes involving Maesters and the Citadel in A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. We’re watching an institution that we know will eventually fail to preserve all the knowledge it should preserve. We’re seeing characters dedicated to the pursuit of learning in an era before that pursuit becomes much more difficult. There’s a sense of watching the light of knowledge burning bright before it fades in the centuries to come.
For fans of the Game of Thrones universe, the Maesters and the Citadel represent something valuable in a dark world: the idea that knowledge matters, that learning is worthwhile, that understanding the world around us is an important human endeavor. They represent the possibility that power doesn’t have to come from swords and political manipulation alone. It can come from understanding, from learning, from the accumulated wisdom of those dedicated to improving the realm. In a universe as cynical as Westeros, that’s a genuinely hopeful message.
Discover more from Anglotees
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.